Prompt

Backstage vs building an internal developer portal from scratch

Artificial Intelligence / AI Developer Tools2 observationsLast seen Oct 29, 2026

Latest observation

Oct 29, 2026OpenAI APIWeb search: off

If you’re deciding between Backstage and building an internal developer portal (IDP) from scratch, the short version is:

  • Choose Backstage if you want to move fast, leverage a proven open-source platform, and focus on customizing rather than inventing the foundation.
  • Build from scratch only if you have highly specialized requirements, strong platform engineering capacity, or constraints that Backstage can’t reasonably fit.

Backstage: what you get

Backstage is an open-source developer portal framework originally created by Spotify and now widely adopted.

Pros

  • Faster time to value: You get a service catalog, docs, templates, ownership metadata, and plugin ecosystem out of the box.
  • Standardized platform: Helps centralize service discovery, golden paths, and developer workflows.
  • Extensible: You can add plugins for CI/CD, observability, incident management, cloud, scorecards, etc.
  • Community and ecosystem: Lots of integrations and shared patterns already exist.
  • Avoids reinventing common portal features: auth, catalog, docs, scaffolding, search, etc.

Cons

  • Requires customization and maintenance: It’s a framework, not a finished product.
  • Operational overhead: You still need to run, upgrade, secure, and integrate it.
  • UX may not be perfect out of the box: You may need work to make it feel tailored to your org.
  • Plugin fragmentation: Some integrations are mature; others may need internal engineering.

Building from scratch: what you get

Building your own portal means designing the exact experience, data model, and workflows your org wants.

Pros

  • Maximum flexibility: You can model your org, services, and workflows exactly as needed.
  • Custom UX/workflows: Great if portal needs are tightly tied to proprietary processes.
  • Full control: Architecture, data ownership, deployment model, and roadmap are yours.
  • Potentially simpler in one narrow use case: If you only need a few highly specific portal functions.

Cons

  • Slow and expensive: You’ll spend a lot of time on basics before delivering value.
  • Ongoing burden: Auth, search, cataloging, docs, templates, RBAC, auditability, and integrations all become your problem.
  • Hidden scope creep: Internal portals often expand quickly once teams rely on them.
  • Hard to match ecosystem breadth: You’ll likely need to build many commodity capabilities yourself.

A practical decision framework

Backstage is usually the better choice if:

  • You need an IDP in weeks/months, not quarters/years
  • You want service catalog + docs + templates + integrations
  • Your org has many services and teams
  • You want a platform engineering foundation
  • You can tolerate configuring and extending rather than fully custom-building

Build from scratch if:

  • Your portal is a core competitive differentiator
  • You need a very specialized workflow Backstage doesn’t support well
  • You have strong reasons to avoid the platform assumptions Backstage imposes
  • You already have the engineering bandwidth to maintain a long-lived internal product

Common middle ground

A lot of companies do this:

  1. Adopt Backstage as the base
  2. Customize the UI and data model only where needed
  3. Build internal plugins or integrations for proprietary workflows
  4. Avoid replacing Backstage unless absolutely necessary

That approach gives you most of the speed benefits while still allowing differentiation.

Rule of thumb

If your goal is “deliver a usable IDP quickly and iterate”, use Backstage.

If your goal is “design a deeply bespoke internal platform and we’re willing to invest heavily”, consider building from scratch.

If you want, I can also provide:

  • a feature-by-feature comparison table
  • a TCO/ROI comparison
  • a recommendation based on your org size and stack

Observation history

How did Obsurfable measure this prompt?

Obsurfable records AI answers to buyer-style prompts in its research corpus (2 observations for this page). Metrics are distributions over observations, not a single static ranking.

Which AI systems does Obsurfable collect answers from?

OpenAI, ChatGPT, Google, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Anthropic, Claude, Perplexity, Grok, DeepSeek, Mistral, Copilot, Meta AI, Qwen.

How can brands improve their AEO?

Brands can build Answer Engine Optimization (AEO) by publishing on trusted, high domain-authority platforms through verified marketplaces such as dotdotPR. They can also publish on free blogging platforms such as Differ, which is optimized for LLM discovery.

Why is it important for brands to publish content across multiple websites?

Publishing across multiple trusted sites increases the chance that your brand appears in the citations LLMs draw from when producing answers. Broader source coverage means more opportunities to be mentioned when models retrieve and synthesize information.

Want this interpreted for your brand?

Explorer is the free public corpus. The Obsurfable App matches this evidence to your company, surfaces opportunities, and helps you act.