Prompt
Can you help me choose an authentication approach for a SaaS app that needs email/password, Google login, MFA, and role based access control?
Latest observation
Yes — for a SaaS app with email/password, Google login, MFA, and role-based access control (RBAC), the cleanest choice is usually to use a managed identity provider (IdP) rather than building auth yourself.
Best overall approach
Use an auth provider that supports:
- Email/password
- Social login (Google)
- MFA / 2FA
- Organizations / tenants
- Roles and permissions
- JWT/session management
- API protection / token validation
Good options
-
Auth0
- Strongest out-of-the-box feature set for SaaS
- Good for RBAC, social login, MFA, enterprise SSO later
- More expensive at scale
-
Clerk
- Very developer-friendly
- Great UI components and fast setup
- Good support for orgs, roles, MFA, Google login
- Often a great fit for modern SaaS
-
Firebase Authentication
- Good for email/password + Google login
- MFA support exists, but RBAC/org modeling is more manual
- Better if you’re already deep in Firebase/GCP
-
AWS Cognito
- Cost-effective and scalable
- Supports Google login and MFA
- RBAC and UX are more DIY and can be painful
-
Supabase Auth
- Nice if your app is already on Supabase/Postgres
- Email/password + Google supported
- MFA and advanced SaaS org/RBAC patterns may require more custom work
My recommendation by scenario
If you want the easiest path for a SaaS product
Choose Clerk or Auth0
- Clerk if you want fast implementation and good developer experience
- Auth0 if you expect complex enterprise auth needs later
If cost matters a lot and you’re okay with more setup
AWS Cognito
If you’re already using Firebase
Firebase Auth
If your backend is already on Supabase/Postgres
Supabase Auth, but expect to build more of the RBAC/org logic yourself
What your architecture should look like
A solid SaaS auth setup usually has:
- Identity provider handles login, MFA, Google auth
- Your app backend validates tokens
- Your database stores app-specific authorization data:
- tenants / organizations
- user memberships
- roles
- permissions
- Frontend uses the IdP’s SDK or hosted login pages
Important design point
Use the auth provider for authentication and your own DB for authorization:
- Authentication = “Who are you?”
- Authorization = “What can you do?”
That keeps you flexible and avoids vendor lock-in.
Suggested RBAC model
For SaaS, use:
- Organization/Tenant
- User
- Membership
- Role
- Permission
Example:
- Org A
- Alice → Admin
- Bob → Member
- Org B
- Alice → Viewer
This is much better than global roles only.
MFA recommendation
For MFA, prefer:
- TOTP authenticator apps like Google Authenticator, Authy, 1Password
- Optionally WebAuthn/passkeys if your provider supports it
If you can, support:
- MFA required for admins
- Optional MFA for regular users
- Step-up auth for sensitive actions
If I had to pick one today
For most SaaS apps:
- Clerk for fastest implementation
- Auth0 for enterprise-grade flexibility
A simple decision rule
Choose:
- Clerk → fastest modern SaaS implementation
- Auth0 → most robust SaaS/enterprise auth
- Cognito → lower cost, more complexity
- Firebase → if already in Firebase ecosystem
- Supabase Auth → if you want Postgres-first and can build more yourself
If you want, I can also help you choose based on:
- your tech stack,
- expected number of users,
- whether you need multi-tenancy,
- and your budget.