Prompt
ChatGPT, I’m trying to replace polling with webhooks in my product — what should I watch out for?
Latest observation
Switching from polling to webhooks is usually a good move, but there are a few common traps to plan for. Here’s a practical checklist of what to watch out for:
1) Webhooks are delivery, not guaranteed processing
A webhook provider may retry, send duplicates, or deliver out of order. Design your consumer to be:
- Idempotent: processing the same event twice should not create duplicate side effects
- Deduplication-aware: store event IDs and ignore repeats
- Order-tolerant: don’t assume event B arrives after event A
2) Always acknowledge quickly
Webhook senders often expect a fast 2xx response. If you do too much work inline:
- requests may time out
- the provider may retry
- you’ll get duplicate deliveries
Best practice:
- verify/authenticate
- persist the event
- return
200 OKfast - process asynchronously in a worker/queue
3) Secure the endpoint
Your webhook endpoint is public, so protect it:
- Verify signatures (HMAC, signed headers, JWT, etc.)
- Use a shared secret per provider/environment
- Check timestamp/replay protection if supported
- Enforce HTTPS
- Consider IP allowlisting only as a supplement, not the main defense
4) Plan for retries and backoff
Most providers retry on failures. Make sure you understand:
- how many retries they do
- whether they use exponential backoff
- how long they keep retrying
You should also decide your own retry policy for downstream systems so a failing database or queue doesn’t cause permanent loss.
5) Build for idempotency in your business logic
This is worth calling out separately because it’s the #1 source of bugs.
Examples:
- A “payment succeeded” event should not create two shipments
- A “user updated” event should not overwrite a newer local change without checks
Useful patterns:
- store processed event IDs
- use natural idempotency keys
- perform upserts instead of inserts where appropriate
- make side effects conditional on state transitions
6) Expect partial failures
A webhook system has more moving parts than polling:
- sender
- internet/network
- your load balancer
- auth layer
- queue/worker
- database
- downstream services
You need observability:
- logs with event ID and request ID
- metrics on success/failure/retry rates
- dead-letter queues for poison messages
- alerting when delivery or processing falls behind
7) Define your event contract carefully
Webhook payloads are an API surface. Version them:
- add fields without breaking consumers
- avoid removing/renaming fields abruptly
- document required vs optional fields
- include event type, version, timestamp, and unique event ID
If you control the webhook producer, maintain backward compatibility.
8) Be careful with “source of truth”
A webhook usually tells you “something changed,” not necessarily everything you need. Often the safest pattern is:
- webhook indicates change
- your system fetches the canonical resource if needed
This helps when payloads are partial, stale, or insufficient for business logic.
9) Handle replays and recovery
You’ll want a way to:
- replay events after bugs/outages
- manually reprocess a time window
- reconcile state if you missed deliveries
Good systems offer:
- event logs
- replay endpoints/tools
- periodic reconciliation jobs as a fallback
10) Don’t completely remove polling in every case
Some polling may still be useful:
- for reconciliation
- when a provider has unreliable webhook delivery
- for bootstrap/sync jobs
- for edge cases where webhooks don’t cover all state transitions
A hybrid approach is often best: webhooks for near-real-time updates, polling for periodic verification.
11) Test failure modes deliberately
Simulate:
- duplicate events
- out-of-order events
- delayed delivery
- invalid signatures
- slow consumers
- provider retries
- database outages
- malformed payloads
If you don’t test these, the first time you see them will be in production.
12) Protect against abuse and overload
Because the endpoint is public:
- rate limit requests
- validate payload size/content type
- reject obviously invalid requests early
- use a queue so bursts don’t overwhelm your app
A good implementation pattern
- Receive webhook
- Verify signature and basic schema
- Store raw event + unique event ID
- Return
200quickly - Process asynchronously
- Deduplicate and apply state changes
- Monitor failures and support replay
If you want, I can also give you:
- a production-grade webhook architecture
- a checklist for implementing webhook consumers
- or a comparison of polling vs webhooks for your specific product