Prompt
Do I need a routing API or can I calculate directions myself?
Latest observation
Nov 8, 2026
OpenAI APIWeb search: off
You can calculate directions yourself, but whether you should depends on what “directions” means for your app.
Use a routing API if you need:
- Turn-by-turn driving, walking, biking, or transit directions
- Accurate travel times based on real road networks
- Traffic-aware routes
- Avoidance rules like tolls, highways, ferries
- Good coverage across regions/countries
- Fast implementation with less maintenance
Calculate it yourself if:
- You only need simple straight-line distance or basic pathing
- Your map/data is small and controlled
- You’re building a custom route engine for a specific domain, like:
- warehouse robots
- indoor navigation
- games
- campus maps
- You already have road/network data and can run graph algorithms like:
- Dijkstra
- A*
- Contraction Hierarchies / other optimizations for scale
Practical reality
For most apps, a routing API is the easiest and most reliable option. Building your own routing system is possible, but it quickly becomes hard because you need:
- map data
- graph building
- shortest-path computation
- snapping points to roads
- turn restrictions
- one-way streets
- traffic updates
- route instructions generation
Rule of thumb
- Need production-grade directions on roads? Use a routing API.
- Need custom pathfinding in a known environment? Build your own.
If you want, I can also help you decide based on your specific app and suggest API options or a DIY architecture.