Prompt
How do I audit AI recommendations for our category?
Latest observation
To audit AI recommendations for your category, you want a process that checks accuracy, relevance, safety, and business impact—not just whether the model “sounds right.”
1) Define what “good” means
Start by writing down the criteria the AI should meet for your category.
Common dimensions:
- Correctness: Is the recommendation factually accurate?
- Relevance: Does it fit the category and user intent?
- Completeness: Does it include the key information needed?
- Consistency: Does it make similar recommendations in similar cases?
- Safety / compliance: Does it avoid prohibited or risky content?
- Business alignment: Does it support your goals, e.g. conversion, margin, retention?
2) Build a representative test set
Create a sample set of real or realistic cases from your category:
- Common scenarios
- Edge cases
- Ambiguous inputs
- High-value cases
- Known failure cases
- Different customer segments / geographies / languages if relevant
Aim for a mix of:
- Typical inputs
- Stress tests
- Negative examples
3) Compare against a ground truth or rubric
For each recommendation, evaluate against:
- Human expert judgment
- Policy / SOP
- Historical outcome data
- Benchmark examples
Use a scoring rubric, for example 1–5 on:
- Accuracy
- Relevance
- Specificity
- Safety
- Actionability
If possible, require reviewers to note:
- Why it passed/failed
- What the correct recommendation should have been
- Whether the issue is due to missing data, model error, or policy confusion
4) Measure performance with the right metrics
Depending on your use case, track:
- Precision: Of recommendations made, how many were good?
- Recall: Did the model miss important recommendations?
- False positives: Bad or unnecessary recommendations
- False negatives: Missed opportunities or risks
- Override rate: How often humans change the AI output
- Acceptance rate: How often humans use the AI output as-is
- Outcome lift: Did AI recommendations improve conversion, revenue, or efficiency?
5) Segment the results
Don’t just look at overall averages. Break results down by:
- Product / subcategory
- Customer segment
- Region / language
- Input type
- Confidence level
- New vs. returning users
- Rare vs. common cases
This helps uncover patterns like:
- The model works well on common cases but fails on edge cases
- It performs worse in certain regions or languages
- It is overconfident on low-quality inputs
6) Review for policy and brand risk
Check whether recommendations:
- Violate internal policies
- Create legal/regulatory risk
- Use disallowed claims
- Contain biased or unfair recommendations
- Misrepresent product capabilities
- Conflict with brand voice
Create a separate “red flag” checklist for reviewers.
7) Evaluate explanation quality if the AI explains itself
If the AI provides reasoning:
- Is the explanation supported by evidence?
- Does it match the recommendation?
- Is it understandable to the intended user?
- Does it hide uncertainty?
8) Run human review on a sample, continuously
Set up a recurring audit process:
- Weekly or monthly sampling
- More frequent review for high-risk categories
- Double-review for disputed cases
- Periodic calibration between reviewers to improve consistency
9) Track drift over time
Monitor whether performance changes after:
- Model updates
- Data changes
- Category changes
- Seasonality
- Policy changes
Compare current outputs to your baseline.
10) Close the loop
Use audit findings to:
- Improve prompts
- Add guardrails
- Retrain or fine-tune models
- Update policies
- Expand training data
- Add human-in-the-loop review for risky cases
Simple audit template
For each AI recommendation, capture:
- Input/context
- AI output
- Human gold standard
- Score for accuracy/relevance/safety
- Pass/fail
- Reason for failure
- Recommended fix
- Reviewer name/date
If you want a practical rollout
A good first version is:
- Sample 100–300 recommendations
- Have 2 domain experts score them with the same rubric
- Measure agreement between reviewers
- Identify top failure modes
- Fix the top 3 issues
- Re-test
If you tell me your category and what the AI is recommending, I can help you design a tailored audit rubric and scorecard.