Prompt
How do I compare my company’s visibility across ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity?
Latest observation
To compare your company’s visibility across ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity, treat each model like a different “search surface” and measure the same things on each one: whether you appear, how accurately you’re represented, how prominently you’re surfaced, and what sources are cited.
1) Define what “visibility” means
Use a few concrete dimensions:
- Presence: Does the model mention your company at all?
- Prominence: Are you the first result, one of several, or buried?
- Accuracy: Are core facts correct?
- Sentiment / framing: Is the company described positively, neutrally, or negatively?
- Citation quality: Does it cite your site, third-party sources, or nothing?
- Actionability: Does it recommend you for relevant use cases?
2) Build a standardized prompt set
Create 20–50 prompts that reflect real customer intent. Group them by category:
- Category / solution: “Best [type] software for [use case]”
- Problem-driven: “How do I solve [pain point]?”
- Comparison: “Compare [your company] vs [competitor]”
- Brand recall: “What is [your company] known for?”
- Discovery: “Who are the top companies in [space]?”
- Purchase intent: “Which provider should I choose for [need]?”
Keep prompts consistent across all three tools.
3) Run the same prompts in each system
For each prompt, record:
- The exact prompt
- Date/time
- Tool used
- Whether your company was mentioned
- Position/order in answer
- Whether competitors were mentioned instead
- Links/citations
- Any factual errors
A simple spreadsheet works well.
4) Score each answer
Create a visibility score per response, for example:
- 0 = not mentioned
- 1 = mentioned incidentally
- 2 = mentioned among options
- 3 = recommended or ranked highly
- 4 = top recommendation / clearly favored
Then add quality flags:
- Correct / incorrect
- Positive / neutral / negative
- Cited / uncited
This lets you compare not just frequency, but quality of visibility.
5) Compare by platform behavior
Expect differences:
- ChatGPT: Often synthesizes from training + web/search tools depending on mode; may favor widely referenced sources and general explanations.
- Claude: Often more cautious and may lean toward provided context or widely available information; can be less “search-like” unless browsing is enabled.
- Perplexity: Usually more citation-heavy and search-oriented, so it’s often the easiest to audit for source-driven visibility.
That means you should compare them on:
- How often you appear
- What sources they use
- Whether they surface your site or third-party mentions
- How current the information is
6) Check the source ecosystem
For each platform, identify where the model is pulling information from:
- Your own website
- Review sites
- News coverage
- Wikis / knowledge bases
- Industry directories
- Competitor pages
If you’re underrepresented, it may be because your company has weak coverage in the source ecosystem, not just because of the model itself.
7) Measure share of voice
For each prompt set, calculate:
- Mention rate = prompts where your company appears / total prompts
- Top-3 rate = prompts where you appear in the first 3 suggestions
- Top recommendation rate
- Citation rate
- Accuracy rate
Then compare those metrics across ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity.
8) Look for gaps by topic
You may be visible for one use case but invisible for another. Break results down by:
- Product category
- Industry
- Geography
- Company size
- Use case
- Competitor comparisons
This helps you identify where your content or authority is weak.
9) Use a repeatable monitoring cadence
Do this monthly or quarterly, because model behavior changes. Track:
- prompt set version
- model version
- browsing/search mode status
- date of test
10) Turn findings into actions
If visibility is low:
- improve third-party coverage and reviews
- publish clearer category pages and comparison pages
- strengthen structured data and public knowledge signals
- earn mentions in authoritative sources
- update FAQ / documentation / definitions
If visibility is high but inaccurate:
- fix brand language on your site
- correct third-party profiles
- publish canonical pages that are easy to cite
A practical template
Here’s a simple row format for your spreadsheet:
| Prompt | Platform | Mentioned? | Rank | Sentiment | Sources cited | Accuracy issues | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best CRM for mid-market SaaS | Perplexity | Yes | 2 | Neutral | G2, company site | No | Mentioned in comparison table |
Best way to interpret results
- Perplexity is best for citation-based visibility.
- ChatGPT is best for synthesis and recommendation behavior.
- Claude is useful for checking whether your brand is understood in broader reasoning contexts.
If you want, I can also give you:
- a ready-to-use spreadsheet template,
- a prompt list for testing visibility, or
- a scoring rubric you can use across all three tools.