Prompt
How do I scrape pages from many domains in bulk?
Latest observation
To scrape pages from many domains in bulk, the main challenge is scale plus variability: different sites have different HTML, rate limits, robots rules, and anti-bot measures. The safest and most maintainable approach is usually to build a domain-aware crawler pipeline rather than one generic scraper.
1) Decide your goal
First clarify whether you need:
- A few known fields from each site
- Full page content
- Links/media extraction
- Recurring updates or one-time collection
This affects architecture a lot.
2) Use a crawler framework, not ad-hoc scripts
For bulk multi-domain scraping, good options are:
- Scrapy (Python): best for high-throughput crawling and scheduling
- Playwright or Selenium: for JS-heavy sites
- Requests + BeautifulSoup/lxml: for simpler sites, but less scalable alone
A common pattern:
- Use Scrapy for discovery and fetching
- Use Playwright only for pages that need rendering
3) Build a domain-aware queue
Create a job queue where each URL includes metadata like:
- domain
- crawl depth
- priority
- crawl delay / politeness settings
- parse template/type
Example:
example.compages may use parser Anews-site.orgpages may use parser B
This avoids trying to force one parsing strategy onto everything.
4) Respect robots.txt and site policies
Before crawling:
- Check
robots.txt - Read terms of service if relevant
- Keep request rates low
- Identify your crawler with a clear User-Agent
- Provide contact info if appropriate
5) Throttle per domain
To avoid getting blocked and to be polite:
- Limit concurrency per domain
- Add random jitter between requests
- Cache responses where possible
- Retry with backoff on 429/503
- Pause domains that start failing
Typical settings:
- 1–2 concurrent requests per domain
- 0.5–3 seconds delay, depending on site
- Lower speeds for smaller sites
6) Separate discovery from extraction
A robust pipeline often looks like this:
Discovery phase
- Start from seed URLs
- Follow allowed links
- Collect page URLs into a queue
- Deduplicate URLs
Fetch phase
- Download HTML / rendered content
- Store raw response
Extraction phase
- Parse fields from HTML
- Normalize data
- Validate and dedupe records
Keeping raw HTML is useful so you can re-parse later without re-crawling.
7) Handle different site structures
For many domains, you usually need one of these:
- Per-domain templates: best when sites are known
- Rule-based extraction: CSS selectors/XPath per site
- Generic extraction: title, meta description, text body, canonical URL
- ML/LLM-assisted extraction: useful, but should be validated carefully
If the sites are unrelated, “universal scraping” is usually brittle.
8) Store and dedupe carefully
Use a database or object storage for:
- URLs
- fetch status
- timestamps
- hashes of page content
- extracted records
Deduping strategies:
- canonicalize URLs
- remove tracking params
- hash normalized content
- track already-seen URLs
9) Implement failure handling
Expect:
- timeouts
- redirects
- captchas
- blocked IPs
- missing pages
- changed layouts
Add:
- retries with exponential backoff
- circuit breakers per domain
- logging for parse failures
- alerting for spikes in errors
10) Consider proxies only where appropriate
If your use case is legitimate and permitted, you may need:
- outbound proxy pools
- rotating IPs
- region-specific egress
But don’t rely on proxy rotation to bypass site restrictions. Use it for reliability, geo-routing, or load distribution where allowed.
11) Recommended architecture
A practical bulk scraper stack:
- Scheduler: queues URLs by domain
- Fetcher workers: Scrapy/async HTTP client
- Render service: Playwright for JS pages
- Parser workers: site-specific extraction
- Storage: PostgreSQL for metadata, S3/Blob storage for raw HTML
- Monitoring: logs + metrics + alerts
12) Simple implementation pattern in Python
If you want a straightforward start:
- Use
Scrapyfor crawling - Maintain a table of domains and crawl rules
- Use
item pipelinesto store results - Add a custom middleware for per-domain rate limiting
- Use Playwright integration only for pages that fail static scraping
13) If you need to scrape many unrelated domains
Then you should strongly consider:
- a generic crawl that collects page text, title, links, metadata
- and a domain-specific extractor only for the domains where you need structured data
That’s usually the only scalable way.
If you want, I can give you:
- a Scrapy project template for multi-domain crawling, or
- a Python architecture example with queue + per-domain throttling.