Prompt
I'm building a code review workflow and want to catch bugs earlier
Latest observation
Oct 16, 2026
OpenAI APIWeb search: off
A good code review workflow can catch a lot of bugs earlier, but it works best when you combine process + automation + review habits.
Here’s a practical setup:
1) Make PRs small
- Keep changes focused and under a few hundred lines when possible.
- Smaller PRs are easier to understand and more likely to be reviewed carefully.
- Split refactors from behavior changes.
2) Use a PR checklist
Add a lightweight checklist like:
- Does this have tests?
- Are edge cases covered?
- Any breaking API changes?
- Any performance/security concerns?
- Is logging/error handling correct?
- Are names clear?
3) Automate the obvious checks
Run these before humans review:
- Formatter
- Linter
- Unit tests
- Type checks / static analysis
- Dependency/license/security scanning
- Build/CI pipeline
This catches many bugs before review even starts.
4) Review for correctness, not just style
Ask reviewers to focus on:
- Logic errors
- Missing edge cases
- Incorrect assumptions
- State transitions
- Concurrency/race conditions
- Error handling
- Data validation
- Backward compatibility
5) Add test expectations to the review process
For every meaningful change, reviewers should ask:
- “What test proves this works?”
- “What test would fail if this regressed?”
- “What edge case is missing?”
If the change is bug-prone, require a regression test.
6) Use domain-specific reviewers
Route PRs to people familiar with:
- The module
- The business logic
- The infrastructure/runtime
This catches bugs general reviewers might miss.
7) Standardize review comments
A simple template helps:
- What changed
- Why
- How it was tested
- Risks
- Follow-ups
8) Encourage “pre-merge debugging”
If something looks suspicious, reviewers should ask for:
- A failing test
- A minimal repro
- A log or trace
- A short explanation of the invariant
9) Learn from escaped bugs
After production bugs:
- Add a regression test
- Update the checklist
- Add a lint/static rule if possible
- Identify the review signal that was missed
10) Track review quality metrics
Useful signals:
- Defects found after merge
- Review turnaround time
- PR size
- % PRs with tests
- Bugs by category
If you want, I can help you design:
- a PR review checklist,
- a GitHub/GitLab review template, or
- a bug-catching review process tailored to your stack.