Prompt
I'm building a creator platform with uploads, comments, and DMs. How should I handle moderation?
Latest observation
For a creator platform with uploads, comments, and DMs, moderation should be built as a layered system: prevent bad content from being posted when possible, detect risky content quickly, and give humans a way to review edge cases and appeals.
1) Start with clear policy categories
Define what’s allowed and what isn’t across all surfaces. At minimum, cover:
- Illegal content: CSAM, terrorism, credible threats, non-consensual sexual content, doxxing, fraud/scams
- Abusive content: harassment, hate speech, bullying, sexual harassment
- Spam/manipulation: bots, scams, mass DMing, engagement farming
- Privacy violations: personal data, impersonation, account takeover attempts
- Platform-specific rules: copyright infringement, explicit content, age-gating rules, creator monetization abuse
Keep policies consistent, but allow different thresholds by surface:
- Uploads: higher risk, more automated pre-publication checks
- Comments: medium risk, mostly reactive + rate limits
- DMs: private, so rely more on abuse detection, reporting, and safety controls
2) Use a tiered moderation pipeline
A. Before posting
For uploads and comments, run checks before content becomes visible:
- Automated text moderation: toxicity, hate, sexual content, threats, self-harm signals
- Media moderation: nudity/explicit content, violence, CSAM detection
- Spam detection: repeated text, links, low-quality mass posting, suspicious behavior
- Hash matching: known illegal or infringing media
Actions can vary:
- Allow
- Allow but label / limit distribution
- Hold for review
- Block
B. After posting
Even with pre-checks, do continuous monitoring:
- User reports
- Engagement anomaly detection
- Repeated policy violations
- Keyword/content pattern detection
- Abuse clusters across multiple accounts
C. Human review
Reserve human moderators for:
- Appeals
- Ambiguous policy cases
- High-severity reports
- Escalations from trusted reporters, creators, or users at risk
3) Treat each surface differently
Uploads
Highest moderation depth:
- Scan media on upload
- Extract text from images/video if relevant
- Review titles, descriptions, captions, and tags
- Consider upload quarantine until checks complete for new or suspicious accounts
- Add copyright workflow if creators can upload media
Comments
Comments need fast, low-friction moderation:
- Pre-check obvious abuse/spam
- Allow creators to:
- delete comments
- block users
- filter by keyword
- restrict comments to followers/subscribers
- Use rate limits, cooldowns, and anti-spam heuristics
- Consider “shadow limiting” obvious spam to reduce abuse without rewarding attackers
DMs
DMs are the hardest because they’re private:
- Provide strong user controls:
- message requests
- allow DMs only from followed users, mutuals, or subscribers
- block/report/mute
- Detect spam, scams, grooming signals, coercion, and harassment
- Use automated safety nudges for suspicious behavior
- Consider stricter limits for new accounts or accounts with poor trust scores
4) Build trust and safety controls into product design
Don’t rely only on moderation after the fact. Product controls reduce abuse:
- Account age-based limits
- Verified status or reputation for high-reach actions
- DM throttling and recipient limits
- URL/link restrictions for new accounts
- Sensitive-content filters
- Creator-side moderation tools
- User-side filters and mute/block controls
5) Use risk scoring
Assign a risk score to content and accounts based on:
- Account age
- Prior violations
- Posting velocity
- Report history
- Network/behavior signals
- Content severity
- Recipient sensitivity (e.g. minors, high-profile creators)
Use this score to decide:
- auto-allow
- auto-block
- queue for review
- step up verification
- rate limit
6) Create escalation paths for high-severity issues
Some categories should bypass normal queues:
- CSAM
- credible threats
- extortion
- imminent self-harm
- doxxing
- child exploitation
- terrorism-related content
Have an internal process for:
- immediate removal or account lock
- moderator escalation
- legal/compliance review where required
- evidence preservation
- mandated reporting if applicable
7) Make reporting easy and specific
Every piece of content and every message should support reporting with reasons:
- harassment
- spam
- hate
- nudity/sexual content
- threats
- impersonation
- scam/fraud
- self-harm
- copyright
- other
Good reporting UX improves both user safety and moderator efficiency.
8) Add appeals and transparency
Users should be able to appeal moderation decisions. Track:
- what was removed
- why it was removed
- whether it was automated or human-reviewed
- appeal outcomes
Publish a transparency page or report with:
- enforcement volumes
- top violation categories
- average review times
- appeal reversal rates
9) Protect moderators
Moderation work can be harmful. If humans review user content:
- blur or hide graphic content by default
- provide content warnings
- rotate difficult queues
- offer support resources and clear escalation rules
- minimize exposure to the most harmful material
10) Instrument everything
You’ll want metrics like:
- report rate
- false positive / false negative estimates
- median review time
- time-to-action for severe reports
- repeat offender rate
- abuse recurrence after enforcement
- creator/user retention impact from moderation actions
11) Practical implementation recommendation
A solid initial setup would be:
- Uploads
- automated scan at upload
- queue risky items
- human review for high-risk media
- Comments
- spam/toxicity filters
- rate limits
- creator keyword filters
- user reporting
- DMs
- request-based messaging
- trust-based throttles
- spam/scam detection
- strong block/report tools
- Platform-wide
- account trust scoring
- repeat offender enforcement
- appeal system
- moderation dashboard and audit logs
12) Recommended rollout order
If you’re early-stage:
- Define policy and enforcement rules
- Add report/block/mute tools
- Implement rate limits and trust scores
- Add automated text moderation for comments and DMs
- Add media scanning for uploads
- Build human review and appeals
- Expand to proactive detection and advanced risk scoring
If you want, I can also help you design:
- a moderation architecture
- a policy matrix by content type
- or a MVP moderation stack for a startup team.