Prompt
I'm building a marketplace with user reviews and photos. What moderation stack should I use?
Latest observation
For a marketplace with user reviews + photos, I’d use a layered moderation stack rather than one tool. The best setup is usually:
1) Ingestion-time filtering
Run every review/photo through automated checks before it becomes public.
Text reviews
Use:
- Toxicity / hate / harassment detection
- Spam / scam / phishing detection
- Profanity / sexual content detection
- PII detection if users may post phone numbers, emails, addresses
Good options:
- OpenAI moderation models / API
- Perspective API for toxicity
- AWS Comprehend
- Hive or ActiveFence if you want a more enterprise trust & safety stack
Photos
Use:
- NSFW / nudity detection
- Violence / self-harm / illegal content detection
- Logo/text extraction if you need OCR-based policy checks
- Duplicate/repost detection to catch spam
Good options:
- AWS Rekognition
- Google Vision SafeSearch
- Hive Moderation
- Sightengine
- Clarifai
2) Risk-based workflow
Not all content should be treated equally.
Auto-approve
Low-risk content:
- Short normal reviews
- Photos that score safe with high confidence
Auto-reject
Clearly abusive/spam content:
- Obvious slurs
- Scam links
- Explicit nudity/graphic content
Human review queue
Borderline cases:
- Sarcasm, reclaimed slurs, ambiguous text
- Photos with mixed signals
- Content from newly created or suspicious accounts
This is important because false positives can hurt legit sellers/buyers.
3) Account and behavior abuse controls
Moderation isn’t just content-based.
Add:
- Rate limiting
- Device/IP reputation
- New account trust scoring
- Link and URL filtering
- Burst detection for fake review campaigns
- Duplicate review detection
- Review graph analysis to catch coordinated fraud
Tools:
- Build in-house rules
- Or use Sift, Arkose Labs, ActiveFence, or similar trust & safety platforms
4) Human moderation tooling
You’ll want an internal moderator dashboard with:
- Queue by risk level
- Side-by-side content and policy reason
- User history
- Previous enforcement actions
- One-click approve/reject/escalate
- Audit logs
This matters as much as the models, especially for appeals and policy consistency.
5) Appeals and feedback loop
Create a process for:
- User appeals
- Moderator overrides
- Logging false positives/negatives
- Retraining thresholds and rules
This keeps your moderation improving over time.
A practical stack I’d recommend
If you want a fast, solid MVP
- Text: OpenAI moderation + simple regex/keyword filters + spam heuristics
- Images: AWS Rekognition or Hive Moderation
- Abuse/fraud: basic rate limits + device/IP reputation + duplicate detection
- Human review: lightweight internal admin panel
If you expect scale and abuse
- Text moderation: OpenAI moderation + custom classifiers
- Image moderation: Hive or ActiveFence
- Trust & safety: Sift or ActiveFence
- Human review: full moderation console + audit logs + appeals workflow
My recommendation by priority
If I had to choose the minimum effective setup:
- OpenAI moderation for review text
- Hive Moderation or AWS Rekognition for photos
- Custom anti-spam/fraud rules
- Human review queue for edge cases
- Logging + appeals
Key design principle
Use multiple signals:
- content severity
- user trust
- account age
- posting velocity
- prior violations
- similarity to known spam
That’s much better than judging each review/photo in isolation.
If you want, I can also give you:
- a vendor comparison table,
- a reference architecture, or
- a policy design for reviews/photos specifically.