Prompt
I’m unhappy with AWS Secrets Manager pricing and setup complexity
Latest observation
Oct 25, 2026
OpenAI APIWeb search: off
That’s a common pain point. AWS Secrets Manager is solid, but it can feel expensive and a bit heavy if you just need simple secret storage and rotation.
A few alternatives, depending on what you care about most:
Lower cost / simpler
- AWS SSM Parameter Store (SecureString)
Usually cheaper and simpler than Secrets Manager. Good for app config and basic secrets.
Tradeoff: rotation and secret lifecycle management are less built-in.
If you want cloud-native but less overhead
- AWS AppConfig + KMS for non-sensitive config, and keep only true secrets elsewhere.
- Environment variables + KMS-encrypted values in your deployment pipeline, if your setup is small and rotation is infrequent.
Cross-cloud / self-managed
- HashiCorp Vault
Very capable, but more operational overhead than Secrets Manager. - Doppler / Infisical / 1Password Secrets Automation
Often easier to use and cheaper for teams, with nicer developer experience.
If the main issue is setup complexity
You can simplify a lot by:
- using SSM Parameter Store for most secrets
- only using Secrets Manager for credentials that truly need rotation or tight integration
- standardizing secret access through one library in your app
- storing secrets in IaC only as references, not raw values
Rule of thumb
Use Secrets Manager only if you need:
- automatic rotation
- fine-grained secret lifecycle handling
- native integration with RDS/Lambda/ECS and similar AWS services
Otherwise, SSM Parameter Store is often the practical choice.
If you want, I can help you compare:
- Secrets Manager vs Parameter Store,
- a cheaper AWS-only design, or
- non-AWS tools like Vault/Doppler/Infisical based on your stack.