Prompt
I'm unhappy with how our asset library handles permissions and approvals. What better options are there?
Latest observation
If your current asset library feels clunky around permissions and approvals, the best replacement usually depends on whether you need:
- simple sharing with tight access control
- formal review/approval workflows
- enterprise governance and audit trails
- creative collaboration with versioning
Here are the stronger options to consider, grouped by what they’re best at:
1) Digital Asset Management (DAM) platforms
Best if you manage lots of branded files, need metadata, versioning, and controlled access.
Good options
- Bynder – strong permissions, approval workflows, brand portals, and governance
- Canto – user-friendly, solid sharing and role-based permissions
- Brandfolder – good for brand management and approvals
- Aprimo – more enterprise-heavy; strong workflow and governance
- Acquia DAM / Widen – robust for large organizations with complex structures
Why these are better
- Role-based permissions
- Folder/collection-level access
- Approval workflows
- Expiration links and download restrictions
- Audit logs and version history
2) Content collaboration platforms with approval workflows
Best if your team needs less “asset library” and more “review, comment, approve, publish.”
Good options
- Adobe Workfront + Assets – strong for marketing ops and approvals
- Box – good permissions, workflow integrations, and governance
- Dropbox Business – simpler sharing and admin controls, less workflow depth
- Microsoft SharePoint / OneDrive – powerful permissions and approval automation if you’re already in Microsoft 365
- Google Drive + Workspace approvals – lightweight, but less structured than a DAM
Why these are better
- Better access controls than many basic asset libraries
- Easier routing for approvals
- Familiar UI for non-technical users
- Integrates well with enterprise identity systems
3) Design workflow tools
Best if the pain point is creative review/approval rather than storage.
Good options
- Figma – great for collaborative review and comment-based approvals
- InVision – traditional design review workflows
- Frame.io – especially strong for video review and approval
- Ziflow – purpose-built proofing and approval workflows
Why these are better
- Annotation and threaded feedback
- Version comparison
- Review stages and status tracking
- Permissions tied to review roles
4) Enterprise content governance platforms
Best if compliance, legal approval, and strict auditability are your main concerns.
Good options
- OpenText
- Box Governance
- Microsoft Purview + SharePoint
- M-Files
Why these are better
- Advanced records management
- Retention policies
- Audit trails
- Granular permissioning
- Compliance support
What to look for in a better system
When evaluating alternatives, prioritize these features:
-
Role-based access control (RBAC)
So you can separate viewers, editors, approvers, and admins. -
Approval workflows Multi-step approvals, conditional routing, and re-approval after edits.
-
Audit trails Who accessed, changed, approved, or downloaded what.
-
Version control Prevents accidental overwrites and keeps history intact.
-
Metadata and tagging Makes assets easier to find and govern.
-
SSO / identity integration Important for scaling permissions cleanly.
-
External sharing controls Expiring links, watermarking, download restrictions.
-
Lifecycle management Assets can expire, get archived, or require recertification.
My quick recommendation
- If you want a true upgrade to an asset library: Bynder or Brandfolder
- If you want enterprise permissions and workflow: Box or SharePoint
- If your biggest pain is review and signoff: Ziflow or Frame.io
- If you’re already in the Adobe ecosystem: Workfront + Assets
If you want, I can also give you:
- a shortlist by company size (startup, mid-market, enterprise), or
- a comparison table focused specifically on permissions and approvals.