Prompt
My domain is authenticated but delivery is still bad, what should I check?
Latest observation
Nov 19, 2026
OpenAI APIWeb search: off
If your domain is authenticated but delivery is still poor, authentication is only one piece of the puzzle. Here’s what to check next, in priority order:
1) Check reputation
- Domain reputation and IP reputation can still be low even with SPF/DKIM/DMARC passing.
- Look for:
- spam complaints
- high bounce rates
- low engagement
- sending to stale/inactive lists
- Use tools like:
- Google Postmaster Tools
- Microsoft SNDS / sender dashboards
- Your ESP’s reputation and inbox placement reports
2) Review content and links
- Spam filters look at:
- subject line wording
- excessive punctuation/caps
- image-heavy emails
- URL reputation
- shortened links
- mismatched display link vs actual link
- Check whether any links point to domains with poor reputation.
3) Look at sending behavior
- Sudden volume spikes can hurt delivery.
- Warm up new domains/IPs gradually.
- Keep cadence consistent.
- Avoid sending to very large, unengaged segments all at once.
4) Confirm list quality
- Remove:
- invalid addresses
- old/unengaged recipients
- role accounts if appropriate (
info@,admin@, etc.)
- Make sure your list is permission-based.
- High bounce/complaint rates strongly damage inboxing.
5) Check the From domain and alignment
Even if authentication passes, make sure:
- SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are aligned with the visible From domain
- your return-path/bounce domain isn’t suspicious or misconfigured
- you aren’t using a different sending domain that confuses filters
6) Verify DMARC policy/reporting
- A domain can be “authenticated” but still have alignment or policy issues.
- Review DMARC reports for:
- unexpected sources sending mail on your behalf
- failed alignment
- spoofing attempts
- If you’re not monitoring reports, you may miss hidden issues.
7) Check for blacklists / blocklists
- Your sending IP or domain may be on a blacklist.
- Some receivers use blocklists heavily; others less so.
- Check major public lists and your ESP’s blocklist status.
8) Examine recipient engagement
Mailbox providers infer relevance from:
- opens/clicks
- replies
- moving mail out of spam
- deleting without reading
- marking as spam Low engagement can reduce inbox placement over time.
9) Test inbox placement
- Deliverability may differ by provider:
- Gmail
- Outlook/Hotmail
- Yahoo/AOL
- corporate filters
- Use seed testing or inbox placement tools to see where mail lands.
10) Check technical mail hygiene
- Proper rDNS / PTR for sending IP
- Valid HELO/EHLO
- TLS support
- No malformed headers
- No suspicious MIME structure
- No forwarding loops or broken list-unsubscribe setup
Quick diagnosis checklist
If you want the fastest path:
- Check bounce and complaint rates
- Check Google Postmaster / Microsoft reputation dashboards
- Confirm alignment + DMARC reports
- Test a few inboxes manually
- Review content, links, and list quality
If you want, I can give you a step-by-step deliverability audit checklist or help interpret SPF/DKIM/DMARC results from your domain.