Prompt
My email provider says everything is fine but users aren’t getting messages. What should I check?
Latest observation
If your provider says delivery is fine but users still aren’t seeing mail, the issue is usually somewhere between sending, receiving, or filtering. Here’s a practical checklist.
1) Confirm the message actually left your system
- Check your app/mail server logs for:
- successful send
- message IDs
- SMTP response codes
- If using a service like SES, SendGrid, Mailgun, etc., verify the message shows as accepted/sent, not just queued.
2) Look for bounces, rejects, and deferrals
Even if the provider says “delivered,” recipients may still reject or defer mail.
- Check for:
- hard bounces: invalid address, recipient doesn’t exist
- soft bounces / deferrals: mailbox full, temporary issues, throttling
- policy rejects: spam, authentication failure, reputation issues
- If you have bounce webhooks or logs, inspect them.
3) Check spam/junk/quarantine
Messages may be delivered but not to the inbox.
- Ask users to check:
- Spam/Junk
- Promotions/Social tabs
- Quarantine or security portal (common in businesses)
- Have them search for:
- sender address
- subject line
- unique snippet from the email
4) Verify domain authentication
Missing or broken authentication is a common cause of silent filtering. Check:
- SPF: does it authorize the sending service?
- DKIM: is the message signed and passing?
- DMARC: is policy causing quarantine/reject?
- Alignment matters: the From domain should align with SPF/DKIM where possible.
Useful test: send to a Gmail account and inspect “Show original” to see SPF/DKIM/DMARC results.
5) Check DNS and domain reputation
- Make sure your sending domain has valid:
- SPF record
- DKIM records
- DMARC record
- reverse DNS / PTR for dedicated IPs
- Review sender reputation:
- new domain or new IP
- recent spikes in volume
- poor engagement
- high complaint rates
- A good provider may still route your mail poorly if the reputation is weak.
6) Review content and links
Filters may block mail based on content. Watch for:
- spammy wording
- too many links
- URL shorteners
- mismatched display name/domain
- attachments that trigger filtering
- broken HTML or image-heavy templates
- misleading subject lines
7) Check recipient-side rules
Sometimes the problem is at the user mailbox.
- Inbox rules / filters
- blocked senders list
- forwarding settings
- alias/group routing
- mailbox quota full
- domain-wide security policy
8) Verify recipient addresses and routing
- Confirm the recipient email is spelled correctly
- Check for:
- typo’d domains
- aliases not monitored
- catch-all behavior
- forwarding loops
- If mail is to a group address, confirm the group accepts external mail.
9) Test with multiple providers
Send test messages to:
- Gmail
- Outlook/Hotmail
- Yahoo
- A corporate domain if possible
If it reaches Gmail but not Microsoft 365, it may be a Microsoft filtering/reputation issue. If it fails everywhere, it’s more likely authentication, content, or sender reputation.
10) Use message headers / trace tools
For a delivered message, inspect headers:
- received chain
- authentication results
- message IDs
- spam filtering results
- timestamps
If you control both sides, compare:
- sender logs
- provider logs
- recipient logs, if available
11) Check rate limits and throttling
If you send many emails at once:
- recipients may defer or silently bulk-filter messages
- the provider may be rate-limiting per domain
- shared IPs can be affected by other senders
12) Watch for suppression lists
Many providers suppress sending to addresses that previously bounced or complained.
- Check your suppression/bounce list
- Make sure the recipient wasn’t auto-suppressed
Fast triage plan
- Send a test email to a Gmail account.
- Check headers and authentication results.
- Review provider logs for bounce/deferral/policy events.
- Ask one affected user to search spam/quarantine and check mailbox rules.
- Verify SPF/DKIM/DMARC alignment.
If you want, I can help you narrow it down
If you share:
- your sending service/provider
- whether it’s SMTP, API, or a mail server
- whether messages are missing for all users or just some domains
- a bounce/error example or headers
…I can help you pinpoint the most likely cause.