Prompt
My email verifier is marking too many good emails as invalid
Latest observation
Oct 19, 2026
OpenAI APIWeb search: off
That usually means your verifier is too aggressive, and it’s likely throwing away valid addresses because of one or more false-positive checks.
Common causes:
- Overly strict syntax rules: RFC-valid emails can look unusual but still be valid, e.g.
name+tag@domain.com, quoted local parts, long TLDs, subdomains, etc. - DNS/MX lookup issues: Temporary DNS failures, blocked resolvers, or slow responses can make valid domains look bad.
- SMTP probing problems: Many mail servers reject verification probes, use catch-all behavior, or deflect with anti-abuse tactics.
- Disposable/role account heuristics: Some “scoring” logic may be labeling valid inboxes as invalid based on risk signals.
- Typos or normalization bugs: Stripping dots, plus-tags, unicode handling, punycode, or case conversion mistakes.
- Greylisting / rate limiting: A server may temporarily refuse connections, which should not be treated as permanent invalidation.
- Catch-all domains: These can make invalid and valid addresses look similar, so hard-failing based on one signal is risky.
What to do:
- Split results into categories: valid, invalid, risky/unknown, temporary failure.
- Treat uncertain cases as “unknown”, not invalid.
- Log every rejection reason and sample false positives.
- Check DNS and SMTP timeouts/retries.
- Compare against a known-good test set of valid addresses.
- Relax syntax checks to accept all RFC-compliant formats.
- Reduce reliance on SMTP probing; many servers don’t support reliable verification.
- Use a confidence score instead of a binary verdict.
If you want, I can help you debug it more concretely if you share:
- the verification flow you use,
- a few examples of addresses incorrectly marked invalid,
- and the specific rule or response that caused the rejection.