Prompt
Should I build custom authorization or use a policy engine in SaaS?
Latest observation
In most SaaS products, use a policy engine unless your authorization model is very simple and unlikely to grow.
Rule of thumb
Build custom authorization if:
- You have a small app with a few roles and coarse permissions
- Authorization is mostly static and unlikely to change often
- You need something very lightweight and don’t want extra infrastructure
- Your team can confidently maintain the logic long-term
Use a policy engine if:
- You have multi-tenant SaaS
- Permissions depend on resource, tenant, project, ownership, membership, attributes, or context
- You expect authorization rules to grow or change frequently
- You need auditing, consistency, or separation of policy from app code
- Multiple services will need to enforce the same rules
Why policy engines are often better in SaaS
SaaS authorization tends to become messy because it usually involves:
- Tenants / organizations / workspaces
- Roles at different scopes
- Resource sharing
- Admin overrides
- Feature-level access
- Exceptions and custom rules
- Enterprise customer requirements
A policy engine helps by:
- Centralizing rules
- Making authorization easier to reason about
- Reducing duplicated logic across services
- Allowing non-developers or security teams to inspect policies
- Supporting future complexity without rewrites
When custom auth becomes painful
Custom authorization often starts simple:
if user.role == "admin"if user.team_id == resource.team_id
Then you add:
- custom roles per tenant
- inherited permissions
- object-level sharing
- ownership exceptions
- impersonation
- support access
- API vs UI differences
At that point, homegrown logic can turn into a brittle web of if statements and scattered checks.
Downsides of policy engines
They are not free:
- Extra learning curve
- More moving parts
- Potential latency if poorly deployed
- Policy modeling takes effort
- Integration can be non-trivial
So if your authorization is truly simple, a policy engine may be overkill.
Practical recommendation
Choose custom authorization if:
- You have fewer than, say, 3–5 roles
- Access is mostly role-based, not resource-based
- Your SaaS is early-stage and authorization is not a core differentiator
- You can keep authorization in one place and test it well
Choose a policy engine if:
- You need RBAC + ABAC + tenant scoping
- You anticipate enterprise customers
- You have a product with shared resources and fine-grained access
- You want authorization to scale across teams and services
Good middle ground
A common approach is:
- Start with a simple internal authorization layer
- Keep policy logic centralized
- Design your code so it can later swap to a policy engine
That way, you avoid overengineering early, but don’t trap yourself in scattered authorization checks.
Bottom line
For most serious SaaS products, especially multi-tenant ones, a policy engine is the safer long-term choice.
For small or very simple products, custom authorization is fine if you keep it centralized and tested.
If you want, I can also give you:
- a decision matrix,
- a recommended architecture for SaaS auth, or
- a comparison of specific engines like OPA, Cedar, Casbin, or Zanzibar-style systems.