Prompt
What attribution model should I use for subscription CAC and payback?
Latest observation
For subscription CAC and payback, the “right” attribution model depends on what decision you’re trying to make.
Short answer
Use first-touch or sourced CAC for acquisition efficiency, and blended CAC / payback for board-level unit economics.
If you need a more granular marketing view, use multi-touch attribution only as a directional supplement, not the primary source of truth.
Recommended approach by use case
1) For board/investor reporting: use blended CAC
Blended CAC = total sales & marketing spend / new customers acquired
Why:
- It captures the full cost of acquiring customers
- It avoids over-crediting specific channels
- It’s stable and easy to compare over time
- It’s the best basis for payback period
Best for:
- CAC trendlines
- Payback period
- LTV:CAC
- Comparing business health across quarters
2) For channel performance: use first-touch or lead-source attribution
If you want to know which channel is generating demand, use:
- First-touch attribution for top-of-funnel demand creation
- Lead/source attribution if your CRM captures the original source reliably
Why:
- Subscription sales often have long consideration periods
- Last-touch can over-credit branded search, retargeting, and sales follow-up
- First-touch better reflects who created the opportunity in the first place
Best for:
- Paid social efficiency
- Content/SEO contribution
- Demand gen reporting
- Top-of-funnel optimization
3) For internal channel optimization: use multi-touch attribution
Use a multi-touch model only when:
- You have enough conversion volume
- Tracking is clean
- You want to optimize across a longer journey
Common options:
- Linear: evenly splits credit
- Time-decay: gives more credit to later touches
- Position-based: more credit to first and last touch
Caveat:
- MTA is useful, but it is often unstable, biased by tracking gaps, and not ideal for CAC/payback calculations.
What not to do
Avoid using last-touch attribution as your CAC basis.
Why:
- It usually overstates the efficiency of bottom-funnel channels
- It undercounts awareness and demand creation
- It can make CAC look artificially good for branded search, referrals, and sales follow-up
Best practice setup
If you want a practical framework:
- Blended CAC → primary metric for CAC and payback
- First-touch CAC by channel → demand generation analysis
- Last-touch or multi-touch → diagnostic / optimization only
Payback period
For payback, the cleanest method is:
Payback = CAC / gross profit per month from the customer
Use:
- Blended CAC
- Contribution margin or gross margin-adjusted ARR/MRR
- Cohort-based revenue retention if possible
That gives you a defensible payback calculation.
Simple rule of thumb
If you need one model:
- Use blended CAC for payback
- Use first-touch for channel sourcing
- Use multi-touch for optimization insights
If you want, I can also give you:
- a recommended CAC/payback formula set, or
- a decision tree for choosing attribution by team/use case.