Prompt
What's the best way to collect publicly available data efficiently?
Latest observation
The most efficient approach is usually API/open-data first, targeted crawling second, full web scraping last.
A practical workflow
- Define exactly what you need
- Fields, geographic scope, date range, update frequency.
- Decide what counts as a valid record before collecting anything.
- Look for structured sources first
- Official APIs
- Government/open-data portals
- CSV/JSON/XML downloads
- Public databases and registries
- RSS feeds
- Only then scrape HTML pages.
APIs are generally much easier to automate, paginate, validate, and keep up to date. The EU's open-data guidance specifically recommends APIs for automated, reusable access to high-value datasets. European Data Portal+1 3. Build a source inventory
Keep a small table such as:
| Source | Method | Fields | Update rate | License | Reliability |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Official API | API | 12 | Daily | Open | High |
| Government CSV | Download | 8 | Monthly | Open | High |
| Website | HTML | 5 | Weekly | Check | Medium |
- Collect incrementally Don't repeatedly download everything. Store a stable identifier and timestamp, then retrieve only new/changed records where the source permits it.
- Use pagination, batching and caching For large APIs, request data in pages/batches and cache responses when permitted. This substantially reduces requests and makes the pipeline faster and more robust. Google for Developers+1
- For websites, crawl selectively
Start from known URLs/sitemaps rather than blindly crawling an entire domain. Respect the site's terms, robots directives, rate limits, and applicable law.
robots.txtcommunicates crawling preferences, although it isn't a security mechanism. MDN Web Docs - Be a polite client
- Set a reasonable request rate.
- Use timeouts.
- Retry transient failures with exponential backoff.
- Don't fire thousands of simultaneous requests.
- Identify your client where appropriate.
Exponential backoff and throttling are standard recommendations for avoiding unnecessary server load and quota problems. Google for Developers+1
8. Normalize immediately
Convert everything into a consistent schema as it enters your pipeline:
source → raw data → parser → normalized records → validation → database.
9. Preserve provenance
For every record, ideally retain:
- source URL/API endpoint
- collection timestamp
- source-specific ID
- original/raw value where useful
- transformation/version information
- Automate monitoring Track HTTP errors, missing fields, record counts, schema changes, and unusually large/small updates. A scraper that silently breaks is often worse than no scraper.
A good architecture
┌── Official API ──────┐
├── Open-data files ───┤
Sources ─────┼── Public database ───┼──> Ingestion
└── HTML pages ────────┘ │
▼
Raw data store
│
▼
Parse / normalize
│
▼
Validation
│
▼
Database / files
│
▼
Analysis / application
Rule of thumb: if you can obtain the same information through a documented API or downloadable dataset, don't scrape the webpage. It will usually be faster, more stable, and easier to maintain. European Data Portal+1
If you tell me what kind of public data you're trying to collect (e.g. company data, government statistics, news, real-estate listings, academic papers, social media, etc.), I can suggest a concrete collection stack and workflow.
Citations
- https://data.europa.eu/apps/data-in-publications-guide/2022-data-in-publications-guide-extended.pdf
- https://data.europa.eu/en/data-in-publications
- https://developers.google.com/ad-manager/api/bestpractices
- https://developers.google.com/analytics/blog/2023/data-api-quota-management?hl=en
- https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Security/Practical_implementation_guides/Robots_txt
- https://developers.google.com/maps/documentation/datasets/web-service-best-practices
- https://developers.google.com/maps/documentation/tile/web-api-best-practices
- https://data.europa.eu/sites/default/files/goldbook.pdf
- https://data.europa.eu/en/publications/reports/toolkit-measuring-open-data-impact
- https://developers.google.com/crawling
- https://developers.google.com/maps/optimize-web-services?authuser=0
- https://developers.google.com/crawling/docs/crawl-budget?hl=es-419