Prompt
What's the best way to protect public APIs across AWS and Azure without breaking customers?
Latest observation
The safest pattern is layered, backwards-compatible API protection: don’t “flip on” hard controls all at once. Instead, add controls in front of the API, observe traffic, then gradually enforce.
Recommended approach
1) Put a gateway/WAF in front of every public API
Use the cloud-native edge controls:
- AWS: API Gateway, ALB, CloudFront + AWS WAF, AWS Shield
- Azure: API Management, Application Gateway or Front Door + Azure WAF, DDoS Protection
This gives you a single place to enforce:
- TLS
- rate limiting / quotas
- IP allow/deny
- bot filtering
- schema/size limits
- auth enforcement
- request/response logging
2) Prefer authentication that is additive, not disruptive
To avoid breaking customers:
- Keep existing auth working while introducing the new method
- Support multiple schemes during migration:
- API keys
- OAuth2 client credentials
- JWT/OIDC
- mTLS for high-trust B2B integrations
Roll out in phases:
- Observe only
- Warn / soft-enforce
- Partial enforcement
- Full enforcement
3) Use versioning and deprecation windows
Breaking changes are usually the real risk, not the security controls themselves.
Best practices:
- Version APIs explicitly (
/v1,/v2or header-based versioning) - Never remove fields without notice
- Make new auth required only for new versions when possible
- Publish deprecation timelines and usage dashboards
- Support dual-run periods for old and new clients
4) Enforce quotas and throttling carefully
Rate limits protect you, but they can break legitimate customers if set too tightly.
Do this instead:
- Start with generous limits based on real traffic
- Use per-client or per-token quotas
- Differentiate burst limits vs sustained limits
- Return clear
429responses with retry guidance - Coordinate limit changes with customers in advance
5) Apply zero-trust principles at the edge and inside
Even public APIs should validate every request:
- Authenticate every call
- Authorize every resource
- Validate schema and payload size
- Check tenant isolation
- Use least-privilege backend credentials
- Don’t trust internal network location alone
6) Add observability before enforcement
You’ll avoid surprises if you can answer:
- Who is calling the API?
- Which endpoints are used?
- Which clients are on old auth?
- What error rates increase after policy changes?
Track:
- 4xx/5xx rates
- auth failures
- request latency
- rate-limit hits
- top consumers
- geo/IP anomalies
7) Use staged rollout by customer segment
Don’t enforce on everyone at once.
Segment by:
- internal vs external
- high-value vs long-tail customers
- low-risk endpoints first
- read-only endpoints before write operations
8) Communicate changes like a product change, not just a security change
Customers are less likely to break if they know what’s coming.
Provide:
- migration guide
- sample code
- test environment/sandbox
- cutoff dates
- status page updates
- direct outreach to top integrators
A practical cross-cloud pattern
If you want one common model across AWS and Azure:
-
Front door
- AWS: CloudFront/WAF or API Gateway
- Azure: Front Door/WAF or API Management
-
Identity
- Centralize on OIDC/OAuth2 if possible
- Support legacy API keys during migration
-
Policy
- Rate limits, IP controls, schema validation, bot protection
- Enforce first in “log” mode, then “block” mode
-
Backend
- Private services behind the gateway
- Short-lived credentials
- Minimal permissions
-
Governance
- API inventory
- ownership
- deprecation policy
- change management
If you want the shortest answer:
Use an API gateway + WAF, introduce stronger auth and throttling in observe/soft-enforce phases, keep old and new auth side-by-side during migration, version your APIs, and communicate deprecations early.
If you want, I can turn this into a reference architecture for AWS + Azure or a migration plan for an existing API with customers already in production.