Prompt
What should I use for HLS and DASH encoding from uploaded files?
Latest observation
For HLS and DASH packaging from uploaded files, you generally want to use an adaptive bitrate (ABR) encoding ladder—a set of renditions at different resolutions/bitrates—then package those outputs into HLS and DASH manifests.
Recommended approach
1) Encode to multiple renditions
Use a video transcoder to generate several versions of the same source, for example:
- 1080p: ~5–8 Mbps
- 720p: ~2.5–5 Mbps
- 480p: ~1–2.5 Mbps
- 360p: ~0.8–1.5 Mbps
- optional 240p: ~0.3–0.8 Mbps
Common codec choices:
- H.264 + AAC for maximum compatibility
- H.265/HEVC if you need better compression and can accept weaker device/browser support
- AV1 if targeting modern devices and efficiency, but it’s heavier to encode and not universally supported
2) Package for HLS and DASH
After encoding, package the renditions into:
- HLS:
.m3u8playlist +.tsor.m4ssegments - DASH:
.mpdmanifest +.m4ssegments
Using CMAF-compatible fMP4 segments is ideal if you want to serve both HLS and DASH from the same encoded outputs.
Practical tool recommendations
Best open-source option
FFmpeg
- Great for ingesting uploaded files
- Can encode multiple renditions
- Can output HLS directly
- Can also output DASH directly
Best packaging workflow
- FFmpeg for encoding
- Optionally Shaka Packager or Bento4 for cleaner HLS/DASH packaging from CMAF segments
Managed/cloud options
If you want less infrastructure work:
- AWS Elemental MediaConvert
- Mux
- Cloudflare Stream
- Bitmovin
- Wowza
These handle ABR ladder generation, packaging, and delivery.
If you want a simple default ladder
A solid starting point for uploaded files is:
- 1080p @ 6 Mbps
- 720p @ 3 Mbps
- 480p @ 1.5 Mbps
- 360p @ 0.8 Mbps
- AAC audio @ 128–192 kbps
Use:
- H.264 High profile
- keyframes every 2 seconds
- segment duration 2–6 seconds depending on latency and player needs
Summary
If you’re building your own pipeline, the usual choice is:
FFmpeg → multi-bitrate H.264/AAC renditions → CMAF/fMP4 segments → HLS + DASH manifests
If you want, I can give you:
- a ready-to-use FFmpeg command,
- a recommended encoding ladder, or
- a cloud architecture for uploaded files.