Prompt
What should I use for retrieval across Slack, Confluence, and Salesforce?
Latest observation
If you want one retrieval layer across Slack, Confluence, and Salesforce, the best choice is usually a hybrid search + vector retrieval system with source-aware connectors and metadata filtering.
Recommended approach
Use a retrieval stack that supports:
- Connectors for Slack, Confluence, Salesforce
- Chunking/indexing of documents, threads, and records
- Hybrid search:
- keyword/BM25 for exact matches, IDs, names, error codes
- vector search for semantic matches
- Metadata filters:
- source = Slack / Confluence / Salesforce
- channel, space, object type, account, owner, timestamps, permissions
- Access control enforcement so users only retrieve what they’re allowed to see
Good architecture
-
Ingest each source separately
- Slack: messages, threads, attachments, channel context
- Confluence: pages, comments, page hierarchy
- Salesforce: objects like cases, opportunities, account notes, knowledge articles
-
Normalize into a common schema
textsourcesource_idurltitletimestampauthorpermissionsmetadata
-
Index in a search engine or vector DB
- If you want strong exact-match retrieval: Elasticsearch/OpenSearch
- If you want semantic retrieval: Pinecone, Weaviate, Milvus, pgvector
- Often best: OpenSearch/Elastic with vector + keyword hybrid
-
Retrieve with reranking
- First pass: hybrid candidate generation
- Second pass: rerank with an LLM or cross-encoder
- Final pass: answer generation with citations
What I’d choose in practice
-
For enterprise search over these tools:
OpenSearch or Elasticsearch with:- Slack/Confluence/Salesforce connectors
- BM25 + vector embeddings
- reranker
- ACL-aware filtering
-
If you want faster implementation and simpler infra:
A managed enterprise search product like:- Glean
- Coveo
- Algolia with custom connectors
These are especially good if you want permissions and connectors handled for you.
-
If you’re building a custom RAG system:
Use:- connectors + ETL
- embeddings
- pgvector or Pinecone
- plus a keyword index for hybrid retrieval
Key gotchas
- Permissions are the hardest part: retrieval must respect Slack channel membership, Confluence page restrictions, Salesforce object-level access.
- Slack is noisy: thread and channel context matter a lot.
- Salesforce is structured: don’t treat it like plain docs only; preserve fields.
- Confluence hierarchy matters: parent pages, child pages, and comments can affect relevance.
Short answer
If you’re asking “what should I use?”:
Use a hybrid enterprise retrieval system with source connectors and ACL-aware indexing—ideally OpenSearch/Elasticsearch for a custom build, or Glean/Coveo if you want off-the-shelf.
If you want, I can also recommend:
- the best tool by budget,
- an open-source stack, or
- a concrete architecture for RAG over Slack/Confluence/Salesforce.