Prompt
What should I use for step-up auth on payments or account changes?
Latest observation
Oct 28, 2026
OpenAI APIWeb search: off
For step-up authentication on payments or account changes, the best choice is usually:
Recommended: WebAuthn / Passkeys
- Strong phishing resistance
- Fast UX on supported devices
- Good for high-risk actions like:
- sending money
- changing email/password
- adding a new bank card
- changing payout details
If you need a second factor as a fallback or for broader compatibility, use:
Good fallback: TOTP
- Authenticator apps like Google Authenticator, Authy, 1Password, Microsoft Authenticator
- Better than SMS
- Widely supported
Avoid if possible
- SMS OTP: vulnerable to SIM swap, interception, and account takeover
- Email OTP: often weak because email is frequently the recovery path
Practical pattern
Use normal login with your standard auth, then require step-up auth for sensitive actions:
- Preferred: WebAuthn/passkey re-authentication
- Fallback: TOTP
- Last resort: recovery flow or support review, not SMS if you can avoid it
For especially sensitive actions
Consider combining:
- recent re-authentication
- device/session checks
- risk scoring
- transaction confirmation details shown to the user
- out-of-band approval for large transfers
If you want, I can also suggest a concrete step-up policy for a payments app or compare passkeys vs TOTP vs SMS in a table.